Summary: A new green biography of eco-billionaire Ted Turner, with author Todd Wilkinson. Kathleen Dean Moore offers a medicine for green despair. Writer and owl biologist Tim Fox sees humans as the unstoppable flood. Radio Ecoshock 141119.
Download or listen to this Radio Ecoshock show in CD Quality (56MB) or Lo-Fi (14 MB)
Or listen on Soundcloud right now!
In this second half of the program, we ‘re going to hear about an answer to ecological despair, from the noted author and philosopher Kathleen Dean Moore. We have a guest interview from Orion magazine. I’ll follow up with another view from author and owl biologist Tim Fox.
FIRST THIS RANT: MUST THE CLIMATE MOVEMENT HIBERNATE THROUGH EVERY WINTER?
Now that the Polar Vortex brings cold to much of North America, the whole climate movement goes dormant. The people don’t know the ocean off New England is 5 degrees above normal, so hot it’s threatening species there with extinction. They don’t know Alaska and Greenland are still way above normal. They don’t know Australia has been roasting again. A vast area of Eastern Australia is heading into another major drought. South Australia just had the driest October on record. But who cares? It’s really cold outside, so there isn’t any global warming….
How can we keep the climate movement conscious through winter in the Northern Hemisphere?
It’s not an impossible challenge. I remember the failed Copenhagen climate summit in 2009. It was bitterly cold outside in Denmark, but thousands of climate activists stood outside the halls. We may have to take climate change so seriously that climate protests continue even when it’s 20 degrees below zero outside. We’ll never make it as “fair weather” environmentalists.
By the way, all the time I was growing up, nobody ever heard of “the Polar Vortex”. It’s like a dam recently broke in the Arctic, flooding the plains and the East with polar weather. Did you know an American scientist named Jeniffer Francis discovered this shift in the Jet Stream may be due to disappearing Arctic ice?
Not enough people know that climate change is really climate disruption, – that it can bring unseasonably cold weather as well as heat. But Matt Drudge and his drones are already laughing at Obama’s China climate deal, because it’s COLD in Washington!
Another thing people don’t realize is that our emissions keep on going all winter. In fact, they ramp up in the North, as all those oil heaters, gas furnaces, and giant coal-fired electric generating plants run overtime. So we’re ducking the whole issue of climate change, while we go into another orgy of filling the atmosphere with our carbon garbage. Winter is a climate killer too. What heats your house?
Another fact about winter CO2: because there are far fewer plants in green during the winter, much more of the CO2 we produce goes into the oceans, or stays in the atmosphere.
I’m almost afraid to do a Radio Ecoshock show on how we are all going to roast. I know plenty of people, myself included, have a subterranean voice that says “mmmm warm, I’d like to be warm”. But the climate movement cannot be season. It can’t be a part-time job. Every month we toss more greenhouse gases into the sky. Don’t stop trying. I won’t.
LAST STAND: TED TURNER IN A TROUBLED WORLD
As The Economist reports, the top point 1 percent of America’s population have as much wealth as the bottom 90% of the people. No wonder some hope this elite will finally turn toward saving what’s left of the planet.
Do the billionaires know? Some do. There’s talk about Richard Branson and his 3 billion dollar pledge to combat climate change. Branson and other bigwigs like Warren Buffet and T. Boone Pickens credit another fellow billionaire for their turn toward green thought and action. That would be the unsung radical rich man Ted Turner, founder of CNN among other things.
There’s a new book out: “Last Stand: Ted Turner’s Quest to Save a Troubled Planet“. From Bozeman Montana, we have the author and long-time environmental journalist Todd Wilkinson as our guest. Find Todd’s web site here.
Download or listen to this Radio Ecoshock interview in CD Quality or Lo-Fi
The secret to understanding Turner, says Wilkinson, is that he always sees himself as the underdog. This develops through a troubled childhood, where nature appears to have been part of Turner’s sustenance. His father, owner of Atlanta’s largest outdoor sign company, killed himself when Turner was 24.
Ted saw some unique opportunities. He bought an inexpensive Atlanta TV station, and hooked it up to a satellite, creating the first “Super Station” broadasting all over the world. Then he bought entertainment companies with rights to old movies, and played those on his growing cable network. Then he developed CNN news, which helped fuel some political change as people in different countries saw how others lived. Some give Turner’s CNN some credit for ending the Soviet system.
Even as Turner was a capitalist on his way to the wealth stratosphere, he still had a yearning to protest the system. I know in the 1990’s he was a big supporter of Greenpeace USA. Then he funded something called the Ruckus Society. They trained young people to climb trees or block bulldozers. It’s wild to imagine a capitalist quietly funding people who protest against capitalist pollution.
BACK TO THE LAND: IN A BIG WAY
Now Turner is the second largest land-owner in the United States, with about 2 million acres. Most of this is old ranches, big ones that were worn out from over-grazing cattle. Turner ruffled some rancher feathers when he said cattle were dirty and unsuited to the terrain. In their place, he introduced the almost extinct Plains Bison.
The Bison can protect themselves better than cattle from predators like wolves and bears. So taking a page from eco-radical Dave Foreman, Ted Turner started “re-wilding” his lands. In Montana, he re-introduced wolves, and now has the largest wild wolf pack in the lower 48 states. He also brought in Grizzly Bears, long extinct in the West. Turner admires Yellowstone Park, and has pretty well succeeded in having all creatures found in Yellowstone also on his Montana Ranch, called the Flying D.
Turner is still a capitalist, maybe an eco-capitalist, with all these ventures. Documentary producer Michael Moore claimed Turner’s land has a higher gross domestic product than the country of Belize. And he doesn’t just raise bison, he slaughters them for the meat he sells in his Ted’s Montana Grill chain.
Everything has to pay it’s way with Ted. But he sees that as justice for coming generations. The thinking goes we can’t saddle them with a “debt” of land that can’t pay for itself. And such lands will not be protected.
Wilkinson also explains that Turner has put easements on some of his lands that prevent them from being broken up in the future. This helps preserve the big corridors, connecting to public lands, that wide-ranging species need.
Turner also believes strongly in alternative energy, and in solar power in particular. He’s put his money where his mouth is. Turner Enterprises has a whole subsidiary where he’s gone into partnerships with large utility companies, (who previously invested mostly in coal plants) to build commercial grade solar electric projects.
In just one example, his Campo Verde Solar Facility in Imperial County California can produce 139 Megawatts. I did a little comparison, and found that is larger than the rated capacity of over 200 coal generating stations in the United States.
Find out more about his solar projects at Turner Renewable Energy here.
Turner money has gone into a wide range of green organizations – over 1,000 of them.
He’s also been concerned about the other big threat to human existence (beyond climate change) – nuclear weapons. With former Conservative Senator Sam Nunne he created a foundation called “Nuclear Threat Initiative”. For one thing, they helped pay for an American team to go grab unguarded nuclear materials from the former Soviet Union – before terrorist could. Find out more about Turner’s anti-nuke weapons foundation here. Warren Buffet has also got on board this one.
Oh yeah, and he gave a billion dollars to a foundation to promote public awareness of the United Nations. It was more than a pledge. He made good on it, giving $600 million himself, and finding $400 million from other private donors.
According to Wikipedia, quote: “In 2008, Turner asserted on PBS’s Charlie Rose television program that if steps are not taken to address global warming, most people would die and ‘the rest of us will be cannibals’.”
Most of our listeners are suspicious of super-rich white men talking about greening the planet. Nobody is perfect. Is Ted Turner our billionaire green hero savior? I asked author Todd Wilkinson that question. He says “no”. In fact, Turner’s wife of 10 years Jane Fonda said Turner was likely trying to save himself as much as the environment. And Turner does fly around to various houses in his private plane, creating super-sized personal emissions.
But Todd wrote the book for a couple of reasons.
First, Turner can influence other very wealthy people and does. He brought Texas wild-catter T. Boone Pickens to realize climate change from fossil fuels is real. Pickens has been pushing wind power. Turner also has influenced some of America’s richest people, like Warren Buffett, and the heirs of Sam Walton, owners now of Walmart. Ted also led the way in saying that at least half of great wealth should be given away, helping influence Bill and Melinda Gates.
More than that though, Wilkinson says Turner can be an example or meme that could help move the capitalist class, or even all of us, to save what’s left of the planet. Wilkinson has been an environmental journalist for 3 decades. He knows how tough it is. A revolution doesn’t seem likely in the near-term. the near-term is all we have left to make big changes, so we may have to get capitalists to care about saving the climate and the biosphere. That debate
continues.
The book is “Last Stand: Ted Turner’s Quest to Save a Troubled Planet”. Judging by the deep info and passion shown in this interview, it should be a worth read. It’s on Amazon of course, but Wilkinson asks you to support your local book store if you can. Find them here.
KATHLEEN DEAN MOORE: HOW TO CHANGE THE COURSE OF A BIG RIVER (or our society).
I have a good connection with Erik Hoffner, a photographer, fish-lover, and outreach co-ordinator for Orion Magazine. He sends me good tips and sometimes guests.
Erik pointed me to an article and podcast with Kathleen Dean Moore. She’s an author and philosopher I admire. I recorded her speech in Vancouver, and broadcast on Radio Ecoshock on May 2, 2012. Find that audio here. It’s titled “It’s Wrong to Wreck the World: Climate Change and the Moral Obligation to the Future“
Now Moore is back, talking about an epiphany she had one sleepless midnight in Alaska – when the temperature even at night was 93 degrees F! (34 C). Talk about global warming!
So this week I’m running that podcast interview from Orion Magazine, with Kathleen and Assistant Editor Scott Gast. She describes how a river changes, and what that means for we who despair of our civilization ever reducing greenhouse gases.
Follow Kathleen Dean Moore at riverwalking.com. My thanks to Orion magazine for this thoughtful interview. Be sure and visit orionmagazine.org.
Download or listen to this segment with Kathleen Dean Moore and Tim Fox, in CD Quality or Lo-Fi
TIM FOX: A DIFFERENT RIVER
We’ve heard the story of the river from Kathleen Dean Moore. But there is another river flowing over the world, and that is us.
Whenever I encounter a nexus of enquiring minds, like Orion magazine, I don’t quit with the main article. It really pays to surf through the intelligent comments as well. That’s how I found our next guest. Tim Fox lives in Blue River Oregon, in the Cascade Mountains. He saw that other river.
So it’s appropriate that Tim tells the tale of a great raging river in the Pleistocene – that age running from about 2.5 million years ago to around 11,000 years ago (though to be the beginning time of modern human civilization). That river came as ice dams repeatedly melted from the glacier Lake Missoula.
Moving up to 60 miles an hour, this vast collection of rushing water – think of a land-based tsunami – reshaped the landscape, creating among other things the “Badlands” of Montana.
Tim’s point: we are that kind of river. Humans are flooding the globe, remaking the landscape as we go. We talk about what that means, and how we can ever hope to change a current like that.
Tim Fox writes for various alternative press outlets. He’s also been an owl biologist. Apparently the famous endangered spotted owl is being threatened not just by habitat loss, but also by one of it’s cousins, the newly arrived Barred Owl.
Some ancient forests in the US Northwest, like those near where Tim Fox lives, are protected under the Endangered Species Act because of the spotted owl. If that owl goes, the forests are no longer protected. Tim calls on us to revere the ancient forest for their own values, not just one species.
In the interview, I ask Tim to read out his very sane comment on the Kathlene Dean Moore podcast, and his own reaction. Tim Fox is a gem worth finding, and I thank Erik Hoffner for putting me, and all of us, in touch with him.
Here are some links to Tim’s writing. His comment in Orion can be found here. He’s just published in the recent Issue 5 of Dark Mountain. Here is his article in Yes Magazine.
That’s it for our time together this week. Our web site is ecoshock.org. Find us on Soundcloud.
If you would like to help this program cover it’s costs and keep going, find out how here.
I’m Alex Smith, saying thank you for listening, and caring about your world.
If it makes you feel better, I never stop commenting on climate change, regardless of the season. If anything, events like the snow disaster in NY spurs me on. Lives are at stake now; they have been for quite some time now. And, my kids could be next.
As usual,I am moved by your podcasts. Green despair is my daily companion. At the 2014 Age of Limits conference, a small group discussed the desirability of continued human existence. With each of the speakers I hear, I more firmly believe that life on Earth might only persist if we are absent. Sadly we will take so much with us in our passing. Humans are the asteroid of our epoch.
75% of river bank and river aquatic life has disappeared in the last 50 years. The U.S. has 75,000 dams. I think the Columbia river has like 8 dams with fish ladders and in 2009, one single salmon made it all the way home past all 8 dams.
THE RUNDOWN
► Humans and livestock were 0.01% of land vertebrate biomass 10,000 yrs. ago.
► Humans and our livestock are now 97% of land vertebrate biomass.
► Humans and our livestock eat 40% of land chlorophyll biomass.
► 50% of vertebrate species died off in the last 50 years.
► 50% of remaining vertebrate species will die off in the next 40 years.
► 75% species loss = Mass Extinction.
► Ocean acidification doubles by 2050.
► Ocean acidification triples by 2100.
► in just 13 years, we will lock in a near term 6°C earth temp rise..
► World Bank says we have 5-10 years before we all fight for food and water.
► Energy demands to increase 50% by 2060.
► Emissions have to decrease 80% by 2060.
► 40% Green Energy requires 200% more copper says John Timmer.
► To power England today with 100% solar & wind, requires 25% of its land says David MacKay.
► Peak copper hits 2030 – 2040 says Ugo Bardi.
► There is no real substitute for copper according to Mat McDermott of Motherboard.
► Post peak copper production cannot accelerate at any price says Dave Lowell.
► This is true of any post peak mineral production.
► We mined 50% of all the copper in human history in just the last 30 years.
► 100% green energy requires 500% more copper.
► Peak minerals includes more than just copper.
► By 2050, expect to be past peaks for tin, silver, cadmium and more.
► We now move 3 billion tons of earth per year to get 15 millions tons of copper.
► We can't afford to mine 500% more copper at ever lower concentrations.
► We cannot recycle it into existence.
► We cannot conserve it into existence.
…
► Green Energy is our solution to Climate Change.
► But, Climate Change is only 1 of 6 Direct Drivers for Mass Extinction.
► The 6 Direct Drivers of Mass Extinction are:
….1) Invasive Species
….2) Over-Population
….3) Over-Exploitation
….4) Habitat Loss
….5) Climate Change
….6) Pollution
► Therefore, Green Energy will not stop the End of Life on Earth.
That Turner guy is responsible for the fall of the Berlin Wall?
Wow, the rest of the interview with that sycophant of a biographer was just annoying and utterly blinded by high level privilege ("He knows what it's like to be an underdog. Nobody believed he would win that yacht race. Oh, and by the way, his parents were rich enough to send him to boarding school." *rolls her eyes*), but that claim about the Berlin Wall is literally the worst insult to my East German parents I've heard in years. To use the bravery of hundreds of thousands of people to go on the streets and risk being shot at, and the sacrifice of all those political prisoners who actually did get arrested for speaking out against the system, just to polish one unendangered and unrelated man's ego and public image, that's truly beyond cynical and loathsome.
And why is it that CNN still doesn't do more to convince people of climate change science than the average American TV channel, if this guy is supposedly so committed to the cause? (As far as I've read, Al Jazeera is the only US TV channel who isn't actively trying to keep climate change out of people's minds by hardly ever mentioning it.)
As for the keeping the activists active during a cold winter: Just tell people to look beyond their own noses. Every time you have a snowpocalypse in the US, Europe gets a winter that's barely worth the name. Last year North-Eastern Germany (continental climate) got all of 10 days with daytime temperatures beneath the freezing point. The winter before that, the arctic air got stuck on Europe, and the snow stayed on the ground for 3 months straight. (Two months of frost with intermittent thaws is what's supposed to be normal.)
Not to mention the diluvial rainfalls that flooded the UK last winter. Or the fires and temperature extremes in Australia that seem to get worse every winter (their summer).
Really, is it truly that hard to make Americans pay attention to what's happening outside of their own continent? The rest of us follow international news as a matter of course.
Hi Cheriola – you are a welcome addition to the blog for sure.
I completely agree about looking at what happens in the rest of the world. But we can't just blame Americans, it's kind of a human thing. In Canada, the news is always about the Canadian angle, with international news left to the last or just left out.
As for Ted Turner: just two things. First, he sold his interests in CNN many years ago. He doesn't control it. When he did, CNN was something of a leader in covering environmental issues.
Regarding the Berlin wall comment. It wasn't that he did so directly. But CNN brought the whole American lifestyle and ideas of democracy to parts of the world that had never seen such broadcasting. No doubt the Soviet authorities, and their puppet governments in East Germany, did as much as they could to block it out – but anyone who travelled couldn't avoid seeing it.
Some changes in technology, which Turner was part of, really can bring unintended changes, just as the Internet is doing now.
Maybe we can also blame CNN for spreading the consumerist lifestyle that America enjoyed as well? I know when I visited a day nursery in the slums of Rio, there was no furniture or paper, except pictures of Mercedes Benz cars on the walls, cut out by kids who hoped to live the glorious lives they saw in the background of shows like "Dallas". Consumer desire spreads everywhere.